Peanut Butter Lover

Sort by:
Sale
BariatricPal High Protein Bars - Peanut Butter

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
BariatricPal Protein Bars - Peanut Butter and Jelly

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
Bell Plantation PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter - Available in 2 Flavors!

Peanut Butter

$ 4.99 - $ 7.99
Sale Price $ 4.99
$ 6.99 Save $ 2.00 ( 28% )
Sale
BariatricPal Protein Bar - Crispy Peanut Butter Crunch

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Cup Patties by ChocoRite

Candies

$ 1.99 - $ 19.99
Sale Price $ 1.99
$ 2.25 Save $ 0.26 ( 11% )
Sale
BariatricPal Protein Bars - Peanut Butter Cup

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
BariatricPal Protein Bar - Chunky Crisp Peanut Butter

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
BariatricPal 14g Protein Bars - Crispy Peanut Butter and Jelly

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
Bariatric Fusion Meal Replacement Single Serving Packet - Chocolate Peanut Butter

Single Serve Protein Packets

Sale Price $ 1.99
$ 3.99 Save $ 2.00 ( 50% )
Sale
Sale
Legendary Foods Nut Butter

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 14.99
$ 16.99 Save $ 2.00 ( 11% )
Sale
Keto Wise Fat Bombs - Peanut Butter Cup Patties

Candies

$ 1.89 - $ 25.99
Sale Price $ 1.89
$ 2.29 Save $ 0.40 ( 17% )
Sale
Kirkland Signature Protein Bars - Chocolate Peanut Butter Chunk

Protein Bars

$ 1.99 - $ 29.99
Sale Price $ 1.99
$ 2.25 Save $ 0.26 ( 11% )
Sale
Eat Me Guilt Free Brownie - Chocolate Peanut Butter Bliss

Cakes & Cookies

$ 3.79 - $ 35.99
Sale Price $ 3.79
$ 3.99 Save $ 0.20 ( 5% )
Sale
BariatricPal 10g Protein Snack Bars - Peanut Butter Pretzel

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
ChocoRite 9g Triple Layer Protein Bars by HealthSmart - Peanut Butter

Protein Bars

$ 1.79 - $ 19.99
Sale Price $ 1.79
$ 2.19 Save $ 0.40 ( 18% )
Sale
Sugar-Free Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars by ChocoRite

Chocolate Bar

Sale Price $ 6.99
$ 9.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 30% )
Sale
BariatricPal Divine 15g Protein & Fiber Bars - Peanut Butter

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
Legendary Foods Nut Butter 16 oz - Available in 5 Flavors!

Nut Butter

$ 11.99 - $ 77.95
Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
Power Crunch Protein Energy Wafer Bar – Peanut Butter Fudge

Protein Bars

$ 2.49 - $ 23.99
Sale Price $ 2.49
$ 3.25 Save $ 0.76 ( 23% )
Sale
Doctor's CarbRite Diet Sugar-Free Protein Bar - Chocolate Peanut Butter

Protein Bars

$ 1.89 - $ 18.99
Sale Price $ 1.89
$ 3.00 Save $ 1.11 ( 37% )
Sale
Protein Cake Bites by Optimum Nutrition - Peanut Butter Chocolate

Cakes & Cookies

$ 2.79 - $ 25.99
Sale Price $ 2.79
$ 3.49 Save $ 0.70 ( 20% )
Sale
Bell Plantation PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter - 2 Flavor Variety Pack

Peanut Butter

$ 9.98 - $ 15.98
Sale Price $ 9.98
$ 13.98 Save $ 4.00 ( 28% )
Sold Out
Pro-Puffs by Meals for Muscle - Chocolate Peanut Butter

Protein Puffs

$ 3.99 - $ 29.99
Sale Price $ 3.99
$ 4.99 Save $ 1.00 ( 20% )
Sale
Quest Nutrition High Protein Protein Bar - Peanut Butter Brownie Smash

Protein Bars

$ 2.45 - $ 24.99
Sale Price $ 2.45
$ 2.99 Save $ 0.54 ( 18% )
Sale
Power Crunch Protein Energy Wafer Bar – Peanut Butter Creme

Protein Bars

$ 2.49 - $ 23.99
Sale Price $ 2.49
$ 3.25 Save $ 0.76 ( 23% )
Sale
BariatricPal 10g Protein Snack Bars - Chocolate Peanut Butter

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
Quest Protein Cookies - Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

Protein Cookies

$ 2.49 - $ 23.99
Sale Price $ 2.49
$ 2.99 Save $ 0.50 ( 16% )
Sale
Quest Protein Cookies - Peanut Butter

Protein Cookies

$ 2.49 - $ 23.99
Sale Price $ 2.49
$ 2.99 Save $ 0.50 ( 16% )
Sale
Nuts 'N More High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - Cookie Dough

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
Nuts 'N More High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - Toffee Peanut Butter Crunch

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
OhYeah! ONE Protein Bar - Peanut Butter Pie

Protein Bars

$ 3.19 - $ 28.99
Sale Price $ 3.19
$ 3.39 Save $ 0.20 ( 5% )
Sale
BariatricPal 10g Protein Snack Bars - Peanut Butter Crisp

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
Bite Fuel Protein Cookies - Peanut Butter

Protein Cookies

$ 2.99 - $ 20.99
Sale Price $ 2.99
$ 3.33 Save $ 0.34 ( 10% )
Sold Out
Nuts 'N More High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - Banana Nut

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
My Protein Bites Cookie - Peanut Butter

Protein Cookies

$ 3.49 - $ 24.99
Sale Price $ 3.49
$ 3.99 Save $ 0.50 ( 12% )
Sale
Nuts 'N More High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - Dark Chocolate 65% Cacao

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
OhYeah! ONE Protein Bar - Peanut Butter Cup

Protein Bars

$ 3.19 - $ 28.99
Sale Price $ 3.19
$ 3.39 Save $ 0.20 ( 5% )
Sale
Nuts 'N More High Protein Peanut Butter Spread

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
BariatricPal Divine "Lite" Protein & Fiber Bars - Peanut Butter

Protein Bars

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 18.49 Save $ 4.50 ( 24% )
Sale
Good Dee’s Sugar-Free Low-Carb Peanut Butter Cookie Mix

Baking Mix

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 13.99 Save $ 2.00 ( 14% )
Sold Out
Snap Nutrition Ooh Snap! Crispy Protein Bar - Chocolate Peanut Butter

Protein Bars

$ 2.49 - $ 16.99
Sale Price $ 2.49
$ 3.50 Save $ 1.01 ( 28% )
Sale
Nuts 'N More High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - Chocolate Maple Pretzel

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
Nuts 'N More High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - Salted Caramel

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
Quest Nutrition High Protein Bar - Chocolate Peanut Butter

Protein Bars

$ 2.49 - $ 24.99
Sale Price $ 2.49
$ 3.00 Save $ 0.51 ( 17% )
Sale
Nuts 'N More High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - Birthday Cake

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
Nuts 'N More High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - Spiced Pumpkin Pie

Nut Butter

Sale Price $ 11.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 3.00 ( 20% )
Sale
Diabetic Kitchen Nut Butter Cookie Mix

Baking Mix

Sale Price $ 13.99
$ 14.99 Save $ 1.00 ( 6% )

Most Popular per Collection:

Trending now: